When the Wrong Answer Creates the Wrong Outcome

A misdiagnosis can feel like a betrayal of trust. You relied on a medical provider to listen carefully, evaluate your symptoms, and provide an accurate answer. Instead, the wrong diagnosis may lead to the wrong treatment, worsening symptoms, preventable complications, or a serious condition progressing untreated.

For many patients, the injury is not only physical. It is the fear and frustration of realizing that valuable time was lost. Some patients are treated for a condition they never had. Others are told their symptoms are anxiety, stress, or “nothing serious,” only to later learn they were facing cancer, infection, stroke, or another life-threatening condition. Misdiagnosis cases require careful investigation, medical expert review, and a strategy built around evidence. At The Stuckey Firm, we work with you, not just for you, and we pursue answers with the seriousness these cases deserve. Your recovery should come first, and we handle the rest. 

What Is a Misdiagnosis Claim?

A misdiagnosis claim is a type of medical malpractice case alleging that a healthcare provider diagnosed a patient incorrectly and that the wrong diagnosis caused harm. Misdiagnosis can involve an incorrect diagnosis, failure to properly interpret test results, failure to order appropriate testing, or failure to refer a patient to a specialist.

These cases often focus on whether a reasonably careful provider would have made the correct diagnosis based on the symptoms, test results, and medical history available at the time. Misdiagnosis may overlap with delayed diagnosis or failure to diagnose, depending on how the case developed. Medical malpractice cases in West Virginia are governed by specific procedural rules and evidentiary standards, including how medical records and privileged information are handled during litigation. Understanding these requirements early can be important when evaluating a potential claim.

person writing on paper

The Benefits of Working With a Medical Malpractice Attorney for Misdiagnosis

  • A Thorough Review of What Was Done and What Was Missed - Misdiagnosis cases require a detailed review of symptoms, testing decisions, and provider notes. Legal counsel helps identify whether standard diagnostic steps were skipped or warning signs were misinterpreted.
  • Expert Support to Prove the Standard of Care - These cases typically require medical experts who can explain what a reasonably careful provider should have done and how the correct diagnosis should have been reached.
  • A Claim That Reflects the Full Impact of the Delay - Misdiagnosis often means treatment was delayed, the wrong medication was used, or the condition progressed unnecessarily. A well-prepared claim accounts for additional procedures, worsened prognosis, and long-term complications.
  • Trial-Ready Preparation When the Defense Pushes Back - Providers and insurers often argue that the condition was inevitable or that the symptoms were unclear. A trial-ready approach helps challenge those defenses with evidence and expert support.
logomark Contact us media

Talk with a local attorney today.

Available 24/7 (304) 407-3177

Does My Situation Require a Misdiagnosis Lawyer in Wheeling, WV?

You may benefit from legal guidance if a wrong diagnosis led to delayed treatment, unnecessary procedures, worsening symptoms, or serious complications. Misdiagnosis cases commonly involve cancer, stroke, heart attack, blood clots, infections, autoimmune disorders, and neurological conditions.

You should also consider speaking with a misdiagnosis lawyer in Wheeling, WV if your provider repeatedly dismissed symptoms, misread imaging or lab results, failed to refer you to a specialist, or treated you for a condition that did not align with your test results. If the consequences were serious, a confidential consultation can help determine whether the misdiagnosis may qualify as malpractice.

The Process for Cases Involving Misdiagnosis What to Expect

Step One: Building the Diagnostic Timeline

We begin by listening to what happened and creating a clear timeline of symptoms, medical visits, testing, diagnosis, and eventual correction. These timelines often reveal key decision points where the correct diagnosis should have been made.

Step Two: Records Collection and Expert Review

We gather medical records, test results, imaging, provider notes, and treatment history. We then consult qualified medical experts who can evaluate whether the diagnosis fell below accepted standards and whether an earlier diagnosis would have changed the outcome.

Step Three: Building the Claim

If malpractice is supported, we build a claim that reflects additional treatment caused by the misdiagnosis, medical costs, future care needs, wage loss, and the broader impact on quality of life. In catastrophic cases, a misdiagnosis may shorten life expectancy or require permanent disability planning.

Step Four: Negotiation or Litigation

Some cases resolve through negotiation, while others require litigation to pursue accountability. We prepare every case thoroughly and work with you to determine the approach that best aligns with your goals.

We build every case with trial-level preparation, even though many settle before trial.

Common Types of Misdiagnosis

Misdiagnosis can occur across many medical specialties and often involves conditions that require urgent testing or specialist referral. Common examples include:

  • Cancer misdiagnosis or delayed identification
  • Stroke misdiagnosis, including symptoms dismissed as migraine or anxiety
  • Heart attack symptoms dismissed or misread
  • Infections misdiagnosed, leading to sepsis or organ damage
  • Blood clots mistaken for muscle strain or routine pain
  • Neurological disorders misdiagnosed or treated late
  • Internal bleeding or traumatic injuries not identified

Misdiagnosis is widely recognized as a serious patient safety issue. The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality provides federal research and guidance on diagnostic errors and their impact on patient outcomes.

“My wife and I are so thankful for The Stuckey Firm. They represented us and advocated for what was owed to our family. We are pleased with their service and their results.”

—B.

city media

Why Choose The Stuckey Firm?

A Client-First Firm That Works With You

Misdiagnosis cases can leave patients angry, grieving, or exhausted. We work with you, not just for you, taking time to listen, explain your options clearly, and help you make informed decisions throughout the process.

Trial-Ready Preparation for High-Stakes Malpractice Claims

Medical providers and insurers often defend these cases aggressively. We prepare thoroughly, rely on strong expert support, and build evidence that reflects the full medical reality, including the consequences of delay.

Credibility That Strengthens the Case

Our attorneys are respected statewide and known for bringing well-prepared, meritorious claims. That credibility matters in malpractice cases where insurers may attempt to argue the misdiagnosis was unavoidable or that earlier diagnosis would not have changed the outcome.

Misdiagnosis Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between misdiagnosis and failure to diagnose?

Misdiagnosis means a provider gave the wrong diagnosis, while failure to diagnose means the condition was missed or delayed entirely. Both can lead to serious harm and may qualify as malpractice depending on the circumstances.

What if the provider says my symptoms were vague or unclear?

This is a common defense. A thorough review of records and expert evaluation can determine whether warning signs were present and whether accepted standards required further testing or referral.

How long do I have to take legal action in West Virginia?

West Virginia medical malpractice claims are subject to strict time limits and procedural requirements. Because misdiagnosis cases can involve complex timing issues, it is best to speak with counsel as early as possible to protect your rights.

Do misdiagnosis cases require medical experts?

Yes. Most misdiagnosis cases require expert testimony to explain what diagnostic steps should have been taken and how the correct diagnosis should have been reached.

How do you prove the misdiagnosis caused harm?

The case often focuses on whether an earlier diagnosis would have changed treatment options or improved outcomes. Evidence may include medical records, expert analysis, and documentation showing how the condition progressed during the delay.

Attorney Media

Get Answers About a Possible Misdiagnosis in Wheeling, WV

If you believe a wrong diagnosis led to serious harm, you deserve clarity. Contact The Stuckey Firm to schedule a confidential consultation and get straightforward guidance on whether malpractice may be involved and what your next steps could look like.

Talk With a Local Attorney Get a Free Case Review

If you’re unsure what to do next, we’re here to listen and help you understand your options

Call Us 24/7: (304) 407-3177
This field is required.
This field is required.
This field is required.
This field is required.
Submit Information

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy (opens in a new tab) and Terms of Service (opens in a new tab) apply.

Accessibility: If you are vision-impaired or have some other impairment covered by the Americans with Disabilities Act or a similar law, and you wish to discuss potential accommodations related to using this website, please contact our Accessibility Manager at (304) 407-3177.
Contact Us